ai research AI Trends Insider autonomous cars robot cars robot taxis Robotics Self Driving Cars Tech

Mass Transit Future and AI Autonomous Cars

Mass Transit Future and AI Autonomous Cars

By Lance Eliot, the AI Developments Insider

Hop on, hop off, hop on, hop off, and repeat till you attain your vacation spot.

Right here in Southern California, a key native transit entity is known as MTA (Metropolitan Transit Authority) and supplies mass transit choices for commuters from all through Los Angeles county. You’ve received mild rail, heavy rail, buses, and the like.

Of the almost 100 MTA stations utilized by commuters to get entry into the transit system, it seems that just a few of these stations instantly intersect with a second line. Which means you should hop onto one practice, hop off at one other station, look forward to the subsequent proper practice, hop on, and perhaps then arrive on the last station you have been intending to succeed in. It appears doubtless you’ll have to make a minimum of two or three such stops and switches, in actuality, because of the lack of stations being interconnected with a number of strains.

You may say that it’s no massive deal and shrug it off as simply a part of the mass transit system construction.

Sadly, it’s a huge deal in that it tends to turn-off riders or potential riders from utilizing the mass transit system. Many individuals understand that it’s too complicated to need to make so many switches. They understand that it makes use of up an excessive amount of time, having to make the switches and sit round for the wanted ready occasions for the subsequent proper practice. All in all, the inconvenience posits them over into avoiding utilizing the mass transit choice for journey.

The much less riders on the mass transit system, the much less priceless it’s having the mass transit system.

It additionally signifies that the shortage of ridership implies there’s much less individuals taken out of the traditional automotive visitors pool.

And, thus, the mass transit doesn’t obtain some key said objectives of decreasing typical automotive visitors, which tends to additionally scale back air pollution, and the mass transit is meant to supply a decrease value various per mile per individual traveled.

Wanting At The Yr 2047 For A Answer

One matter being mentioned and debated right here in Southern California is the proposed improvement of a brand new north-south backbone that might run all through central L.A. and create extra intersecting factors with the prevailing stations. Based on Metro, the brand new line would probably serve 90,000 journeys a day and grow to be the busiest light-rail line in the USA.

If all goes nicely when it comes to continuing to construct the brand new line, it will open within the yr 2047.

That’s proper, the official ribbon slicing for the primary ridership can be about 30 years from now.


For many of us, it’s exhausting to think about ready thirty years for one thing. When you have young children, they’ll be center aged by the point the brand new line is operating. In case you are center aged now, you’ll possible be nearing retirement. In case you are already retired now, I can solely hope you’ll be round to return and see the grand unveiling of the brand new line.

When it comes to development value, it’s estimated that it might be round $150 million per mile (totaling a price of about $three billion), if constructed at road degree.

Some say that it shouldn’t be at road degree, and as an alternative be positioned both above floor by way of an aerial line, or perhaps place all of it underground. These proposed choices are costlier, together with for instance that the underground strategy would possible be round $700 million per mile (complete undertaking value of $four.7 billion). These are projected prices, of which there are some critics that say it’s method under-estimated and the true price ticket might be a lot bigger.

There’s a group pushing to get the undertaking finished sooner and needs to have the brand new line underway by the point the 2028 Summer time Olympics come to Los Angeles.

Hey, mark that yr in your calendar to return go to L.A. within the yr 2028. Be right here, or be sq..

Anyway, aiming to shave about 20 years off the 2047 forecasted date would definitely be a pleasant want to have happen. However, whether or not you’ll be able to speed up a challenge of this magnitude, given all the regulatory hurdles, the political elements, and the remaining, together with what it’d as a consequence of pushing up the price, nicely, let’s simply say it’s nonetheless a dream for the second.

Concentrate on the yr 2047.

Assume significantly about it.

Place your thoughts into the longer term.

The Future Ought to Embrace AI Autonomous Automobiles

What does this need to do with AI self-driving driverless autonomous automobiles?

Relying upon whom you consider, we’re presumably going to have fairly numerous AI self-driving automobiles on our roadways by the point that the yr 2047 rolls round. One notable prediction talked about in a Fortune journal article has predicted that by the yr 2040 that about 95% of latest automobiles bought in the USA can be AI self-driving automobiles (see:

If that’s the case, it might are likely to recommend that by the yr 2047 there will probably be a plentiful variety of AI autonomous automobiles cruising round our highways and byways.

Some clarifications are wanted.

Proper now, there are an estimated 200+ million typical automobiles in america.

Every time AI self-driving automobiles begin to turn out to be available, it’s going to take some time to show over the inventory of typical automobiles to turn out to be AI self-driving automobiles. I’ve talked about many occasions that I’m uncertain there will probably be a lot in the best way of kits to retrofit typical automobiles, and that as an alternative you’ll want to purchase a brand new automotive that’s outfitted as an AI self-driving automotive. And, since most individuals can’t simply outright ditch their present automotive and purchase a brand new one, the chances are that it’ll take a few years for AI self-driving automobiles to turn out to be extensively populated on our roads.

See my article about kits for AI self-driving automobiles:

See my article about induced demand as a result of AI self-driving automobiles:

If we go together with the notion that it gained’t be till about 2040 that the predominant new automotive buy will include AI self-driving automobiles, it means that through the 2020’s and the 2030’s we’ll have a mixture of typical automobiles and AI self-driving automobiles, however that typical automobiles will nonetheless be the dominant mode of automotive visitors on our roads.

I’ve emphasised this facet many occasions too as a result of there are some AI self-driving automotive pundits that hold mentioning a nirvana world of all and solely AI self-driving automobiles on our streets, however this simply isn’t going to occur for a really very long time.

It’s essential to comprehend that there are numerous ranges of AI self-driving automobiles. The topmost degree is Degree 5, which is the purpose at which an AI self-driving automotive can drive the automotive with none human intervention wanted. Certainly, there’s often no provision within the automotive for any human driving, resembling there’s the elimination of the pedals and the steering wheel. No matter a human might do when it comes to driving the automotive, it’s anticipated that the AI will do as an alternative for a Degree 5 AI self-driving automotive.

In the course of the 2020’s and the 2030’s, we’ll undoubtedly see plenty of automobiles which are on the ranges 2 and three, and maybe some on the degree four, however presumably only a few on the true Degree 5. There can be some intense and acrimonious debate about whether or not a self-driving automotive has truly achieved a Degree 5, and which is a side not so simply decided.

See my article about ranges of AI self-driving automobiles:

See my article a few Turing check for AI self-driving automobiles:

See my framework about AI self-driving automobiles:

Returning to the matter at-hand, I started by mentioning that the Los Angeles mass transit system is proposing so as to add a brand new line at a price of maybe $three billion to $5 billion dollars, and that it gained’t be prepared till 2047 (until there’s a miracle and Santa Claus ship it earlier, similar to by the yr 2028).

Arduous-To-Digest Questions About Future Mass Transit

Right here’s the million greenback (or billion greenback) query: Do we’d like extra mass transit by the point we attain the mid-2040’s and past?

If we’re going to have widespread AI self-driving automobiles by that very same time-frame, maybe we’re pouring cash into including mass transit that may finally have been for not.

In different phrases, sure let’s maintain the prevailing mass transit system going, since we presumably want it through the subsequent 30 years or so for functions of shoring up the shortage of widespread AI self-driving automobiles, however perhaps we must be doing a “intestine verify” as to beginning to construct one thing that gained’t come obtainable till a future during which it perhaps gained’t be wanted.

It’s maybe a bridge to nowhere, as they are saying.

By the best way, as an fascinating apart, we have already got a bridge to nowhere right here in California, based mostly in our San Gabriel mountains.

Again in 1936, there was an effort to construct an arch bridge that was going to attach with a street that might result in San Gabriel Valley. The bridge acquired constructed. The street obtained washed out in 1938. The choice was made that it was not value the price to proceed. The bridge now simply sits there. Sometimes, individuals come to take a look at it and a few attempt to parachute off it. It’s formally generally known as the “Bridge to Nowhere.”

In any case, any mass transit venture that’s going to get began now or within the close to future, and for which it’d take 30 years or extra to get constructed, we in all probability ought to look within the mirror and say can we like what we see?

Does it make sense to pump cash into such tasks?

Although I’ve introduced up the query within the context of the Los Angeles mass transit, it appears prudent to ask the identical query about any mass transit proposed anyplace in the USA.

Go searching in your geographical space and ask your self whether or not including mass transit is worth it if certainly there can be prevalent autonomous automobiles.

One argument in favor of continuing on the mass transit undertaking can be that we don’t actually know when the arrival might be of AI self-driving automobiles when it comes to a timeline, and thus it’s an inexpensive hedge guess to imagine that mass transit will nonetheless be wanted by 2047. It’s conceivable that we gained’t have many AI self-driving automobiles by then, and as an alternative perhaps it is going to be one other twenty or thirty years later, comparable to maybe 2060 or 2070. In that case, full-steam forward with extra mass transit till we attain these later dates.

Contemplate The Commerce-offs Concerned

One other argument in favor of continuing with large multi-decades lengthy mass transit tasks can be that even when AI self-driving automobiles are fashionable by 2047, perhaps we’ll nonetheless want mass transit.

Let’s contemplate that facet, analyzing the positions each in-favor and opposing to it.

Some consider that with the prevalence of AI self-driving automobiles, we’re going to have a ridesharing-as-an-economy way of life.

Which means ridesharing would be the dominant mode of journey and that we’ll be utilizing AI self-driving automobiles to take action.

People who purchase AI self-driving automobiles will understand that they don’t want to make use of it 24×7, despite the fact that it may be used 24×7 usually as a result of it has an digital chauffeur all the time on the prepared. So, individuals will flip their AI self-driving automotive right into a ridesharing service. Some will buy an AI self-driving automotive purposely to be a ridesharing service and use it virtually solely and just for earning money as a ridesharing mechanism.

Some assert that autonomous automobiles can be primarily fleet owned, comparable to by a big automaker, or a big tech agency, or a big ridesharing agency, or actually any sizable agency that thinks they will earn cash through the use of self-driving driverless automobiles for ridesharing functions. Although I’m emphasizing giant sized corporations doing this, it might very nicely be that plenty of mini-fleets sprout too, by medium sized companies and smaller companies.

People may additionally purchase a number of driverless automobiles and create their very own micro-sized fleet, making a type of cottage business.

For my article about continuous AI self-driving automobiles:

For my article concerning the affordability of autonomous automobiles, see:

On the subject of Gen-Z and the emergence of driverless automobiles, see my article:

If that occurs, would anybody need to use mass transit?

Commuters can use the comfort of an autonomous automotive that gives their very own personal bubble, because it have been, and can take them on to the place they need to go, they don’t want to attend to make use of it, and presumably the fee shall be comparatively low since there’ll such an ample provide of those AI self-driving automobiles roaming and roving round.

Moreover, the AI self-driving automotive can cowl the final mile for them.

The vaunted and prized “final mile” is a reference to the issue that the majority mass transit choices can’t get you to your precise desired vacation spot.

You may want to get from a practice station to that grocery retailer or your property, and so the mass transit isn’t full. In the meantime, the AI self-driving automotive might take you on the brief hauls and even the longer hauls, in concept.

You may argue that each one these AI self-driving automobiles can be polluting and fuel guzzlers, which is the rationale why mass transit is best, ecologically. However, the chances are that the majority if not all AI self-driving automobiles are going to be electrical automobiles. Subsequently, no fuel guzzling, and little or no pollution. The mass transit ecological argument is legitimate immediately as a result of we’ve so many typical automobiles and they’re just about fuel fueled. It appears unlikely that’s the best way that AI self-driving automobiles might be.

Plus, some consider that there will probably be probably a Private Speedy Transit (PRT) system consisting of a way to have an autonomous automotive experience on a sled or comparable conveyance platform, whisking the driverless in a train-like system to a vacation spot level, after which the autonomous automotive will disembark and drive the remainder of the best way to the specified vacation spot.

For my article about Private Speedy Transit and driverless automobiles, see:

For my article about autonomous automobiles being EV’s, see:

The aforementioned features appear to recommend that we gained’t want mass transit. Which may appear harsh.

Suppose as an alternative we are saying that we’ll want much less mass transit, however not get rid of it completely. There’ll nonetheless be circumstances maybe of not wanting to make use of an AI self-driving automotive and as an alternative experience on a practice or a bus.

We additionally want to think about that presumably if the AI is sweet sufficient to drive a automotive, it might appear to be ok to possible drive a bus, and drive a practice. In that case, we’ve taken the labor prices out of the bus driving and the practice driving.

This maybe makes mass transit much more reasonably priced, at the least on an ongoing foundation (it nonetheless wouldn’t appear to dampen the preliminary development value).

How Huge Is Huge

In the USA, there’s about $65 billion spent yearly towards the continued maintenance of our nations mass transit methods.

The typical journey size is round 5.5 miles.

There are an estimated 433,000 individuals employed by mass transit in America, of which 97% of them are within the operational points of mass transit.

These are numbers offered by the American Public Transportation Affiliation (APTA).

If AI self-driving automobiles have been to emerge and if it meant that mass transit would progressively disappear or dramatically scale-down, presumably this might imply that the $65 billion yearly being spent immediately might go to different makes use of.

What would occur to the almost half one million individuals employed by mass transit? Seemingly, hopefully, the ramp down of mass transit would happen over a prolonged sufficient interval that these individuals would be capable of shift to another space of the financial system.

In response to the mass transit business, for every $1 billion added funding in mass transit, these invested dollars helps the creation of probably 50,000 jobs. If we as soon as once more assume the state of affairs of not making these mass transit investments, no less than for investments involving mass transit that gained’t come on-line till 2047 or thereabouts, it means that these added jobs can’t be counted on to materialize.

Think about one other concept. May the arrival of AI self-driving automobiles generate the identical type of jobs enlargement, in lieu of the mass transit?


With all of these AI self-driving automobiles, and going across the clock, there’s going to be numerous want for upkeep and maintenance of these automobiles. A automotive continues to be a automotive. It can break down.

In all probability much more so than now, because the self-driving automobiles may be run on a regular basis. Presumably, a lot of human specialists for doing upkeep and repairs can be wanted, at the very least till it may be automated by way of robotics or comparable know-how.

For my article concerning the repairs points of autonomous automobiles, see:

For driverless automobiles and the query of being an financial commodity, see my article:

For my article concerning the altering panorama of jobs because of the creation of driverless automobiles, see:


At this time, there are an estimated 5% of automobiles in the USA which are getting used for ridesharing.

By the yr 2040, some predictions are that 68% of automobiles will probably be used for ridesharing.

This opens up an incredible capability for doing ridesharing. It looks like this shift must take away ridership from someplace else, and thus mass transit could possibly be one place that will get decreased when it comes to ridership as commuters shift over to utilizing AI self-driving automobiles.

As a aspect observe, some consider that mobility at the moment is suppressed and never absolutely exercised because of the arduous and dear features of transportation, subsequently, the arrival of extra available and reasonably priced mobility may uncork the bottle, specifically unleashing the suppressed want, a phenomena also known as induced demand.  

For my article about induced demand and autonomous automobiles, see:

Individuals in the present day that don’t journey, or solely journey to a point N, they’ll all now choose to journey and achieve this for some heightened quantity Z. In the event you consider in that notion, it might be that with such an enormous scaling up of demand for journey, the mass transit nonetheless stays in place.

We’d want each the arrival of AI self-driving automobiles and the continued functionality of mass transit to deal with all of that gargantuan demand.

During the last 20 years or so, the expansion of mass transit passenger miles has eclipsed the variety of automotive miles traveled (per the APTA stats). Mass transit although nonetheless solely is utilized by a comparatively small proportion of the touring public. With the emergence and finally prevalence of AI self-driving automobiles, it might sound affordable to anticipate that the variety of automotive miles traveled won’t solely eclipse the mass transit passenger miles, however achieve this by maybe a dramatic quantity.

We additionally want to think about the chance prices related to spending on future mass transit expansions.

If the Los Angeles line enlargement will get the wanted $three to $5 billion dollars in spending, of which some will come from native sources and a few from federal (perhaps half from federal), might that cash have been put to another use as an alternative? If it’s a bridge to nowhere, perhaps there’s different tasks that might be a wiser funding. Then again, because the billions shall be spent over the subsequent thirty years, you might a minimum of say that it has had a advantage of hiring the folks that did the development throughout that time period (and different aspect financial advantages).

These speculations contain all types of financial guesses and in addition technological guesses.

When will AI self-driving automobiles grow to be prevalent?

Will they be as protected as mass transit?

Will they be as dependable?

Will they be kind of pricey than mass transit?

I’m positive you’ve heard the phrase “voodoo economics” having been used, typically in a condescending approach, when referring to speculative financial theories which are being espoused.

For AI self-driving automobiles, maybe we’ve acquired a little bit of “voodoo predictions” about when AI self-driving automobiles will really be viable and develop into a mainstay in society.

Whether or not or not we should always guess on the way forward for mass transit based mostly on the voodoo predictions is a troublesome name. Some say play it protected and construct a possible bridge to nowhere, in case it seems to be a bridge to someplace, whereas others decry this type of logic and say don’t put good cash after dangerous.

Guess we’d like time to let this play out, and perhaps a transportation “witch physician” to type this out.

Copyright 2019 Dr. Lance Eliot

This content material is initially posted on AI Tendencies.

About the author